Josh Gottheimer, the four-term congressman and gubernatorial candidate, is eager to prove just how in-tune he is with the people of New Jersey. His campaign trail strategy? Highlighting his deep appreciation for Bruce Springsteen—an homage that seems almost mandatory for any Garden State politician—and making his Spotify Wrapped public.

In a move that could backfire spectacularly, Josh Gottheimer unveiled his Spotify Wrapped list for 2024, touting a playlist packed with blue-collar anthems, timeless rock classics, and nostalgic Jersey Shore jams. While the list seems meticulously designed to resonate with New Jersey voters, its uncanny perfection has sparked a storm of skepticism—and could sink his campaign.

The top five most-played artists? All Bruce Springsteen. Every single spot.

The over-the-top relatability has critics and voters raising eyebrows, with many calling it a blatant fabrication. Social media erupted with claims that the playlist feels too staged, pointing to the calculated nature of modern political campaigns, where even coffee orders and shoe brands are strategically selected. Crafting a fake Spotify Wrapped? A no-brainer.

If Gottheimer’s Wrapped is indeed a phony, it could spell disaster for his gubernatorial ambitions, painting him as a fake candidate pandering for votes. Authenticity is everything, and this misstep might have just hit the wrong note.

Whether this controversy sparks genuine connection or solidifies doubts, one thing is clear: New Jersey voters are paying attention—and the congressman’s campaign is skating on thin ice.